What is the International Court of Justice?

By Beyond Headlines

Explainer -

International Court of Justice Headquarter in 2006 | Source: Wikimedia Commons

The International Court of Justice (ICJ) has drawn global attention after delivering a landmark judgment against Myanmar, holding the country responsible for committing genocide against its Rohingya population during the military's brutal operations in Rakhine State in 2017.

The ruling has stirred fresh curiosity about the court's authority, its jurisdiction and its power to hold states accountable for violations of international law, particularly because the ICJ remains one of the least understood institutions in the international legal system.

So, what exactly is the ICJ? How does it work, who are its judges, and what powers does it have over sovereign states?

ORIGINS AND HISTORY

Established in June 1945 under the Charter of the United Nations, the ICJ, widely known as the 'World Court', began its work in April 1946.

Based in the Peace Palace in The Hague, the Netherlands, it is one of the UN's six principal organs. It replaced the Permanent Court of International Justice, established in 1922 under the League of Nations, the UN's predecessor.

Created as part of the post-Second World War international order, the ICJ has two primary functions: settling legal disputes between states in accordance with international law and providing advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by authorised UN bodies and agencies.

It is the only international court that settles disputes between the 193 UN member states. However, the ICJ is not a supreme court to which national courts can turn; it hears cases involving sovereign states when requested, not individuals or companies.

JUDGES AND APPOINTMENTS

The ICJ consists of 15 independent judges, elected for nine-year terms by the UN General Assembly and the Security Council. Elections take place every three years, with five judges elected each time, allowing for continuity in the court's work. Judges can be re-elected.

They are chosen from among people of high moral character who are qualified for the highest judicial positions in their respective countries or recognised as experts in international law. No two judges can be nationals of the same country at the same time.

Although judges are nominated by their respective countries, they do not represent their governments or national interests. They are expected to act independently and impartially. The court elects its own president and vice-president for three-year terms.

The composition is also intended to reflect the world's major legal systems and geographical regions. This helps ensure that the court does not become dominated by the legal traditions of a particular group of countries.

The ICJ is assisted by a Registry, which serves as its administrative organ. Its official languages are English and French.

WHO CAN APPROACH THE ICJ?

Unlike national courts, where individuals or organisations can bring cases against others, only UN member states can bring a case against any other member state, whether or not they are directly in conflict, when the common interest of the international community is at stake. 

The case against Myanmar, for instance, was brought by The Gambia in November 2019 under the 1948 Genocide Convention. The country was not directly concerned by the genocide allegations levelled against Myanmar, but that did not preclude the country from bringing the action, on behalf of the Organisation of Islamic Cooperation, according to the UN website.

The 1948 treaty allows member states to bring disputes concerning its interpretation, application or fulfilment before the ICJ.

The Gambia argued that Myanmar had violated its obligations under the convention to prevent and punish genocide against the Rohingya.

A case typically begins with an application filed by one state. Both sides then submit written arguments, followed by public hearings where their legal teams present their positions and answer questions from the judges. The judges deliberate in private before delivering a judgment, generally by majority vote.

However, the ICJ cannot automatically hear a dispute simply because one country accuses another of violating international law. Its jurisdiction generally depends on the consent of the states involved.

Countries may accept the court's authority through a special agreement, a declaration recognising its compulsory jurisdiction or a clause in an international treaty that allows disputes to be referred to it.

JURISDICTION AND POWERS

The ICJ's most important power is its authority to deliver legally binding judgments in disputes between states that have accepted its jurisdiction. Once a judgment is delivered, it is final and cannot be appealed. The decision, however, is binding only on the countries involved in that particular case.

The court can determine whether a country has violated an international treaty or its obligations under international law. It can also order states to stop unlawful actions, fulfil their legal obligations, provide assurances against future violations and make reparations for damage caused.

In the Myanmar case, for example, the court found the country responsible for genocide against the Rohingya and ordered it to take steps to prevent further violations, investigate and punish those responsible, facilitate the safe, voluntary and dignified return of displaced Rohingya and provide compensation.

The ICJ also has the authority to issue provisional measures – urgent directions to parties while a case is still under consideration. These are intended to prevent irreparable harm to the rights at stake. In January 2020, the court ordered Myanmar to take measures to prevent acts of genocide and preserve evidence related to the case.

Its second function is to provide advisory opinions on legal questions referred to it by authorised UN bodies, including the General Assembly and Security Council. These opinions are generally not legally binding, but they carry considerable legal weight and can influence international law and policy.

ENFORCING ITS JUDGMENTS

Despite its authority, the ICJ has no police force, military or independent enforcement machinery to compel countries to obey its decisions. Its effectiveness therefore depends largely on states' willingness to comply and the international community's ability to exert pressure.

Under Article 94 of the UN Charter, every UN member state undertakes to comply with ICJ judgments in cases to which it is a party. If a country fails to do so, the other party can take the matter to the UN Security Council, which may make recommendations or decide on measures to enforce the judgment.

However, this route has limitations. Any substantive Security Council action can be blocked by a veto from one of its five permanent members – China, France, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States.

ICJ VS ICC

The ICJ is often confused with another Hague-based institution: the International Criminal Court (ICC). But the two have very different roles.

While the ICJ deals with legal disputes between states and determines their responsibility under international law, the ICC prosecutes individuals accused of genocide, war crimes, crimes against humanity and the crime of aggression.

The ICJ cannot send a country's leader or military commander to prison. Determining individual criminal responsibility and prosecuting those accused of international crimes fall under the jurisdiction of criminal courts, including the ICC and national courts.

The distinction is important in the Myanmar case: the ICJ has determined the state's responsibility for genocide, but that does not automatically establish the criminal guilt of any particular individual.

Softer penalties, same old concerns

Draft Cyber Protection Act / Softer penalties, same old concerns

Bangladesh’s draft Cyber Protection Act lowers penalties for rumours and misinformation and adds safeguards for registered media outlets, but retains warrantless searches, arrests, content-blocking powers and official immunity.

- Explainer

How 9/11 changed air travel forever

How 9/11 changed air travel forever

How the 9/11 attacks reshaped air travel worldwide, leading to stricter airport security, enhanced screening, reinforced cockpit doors, tighter baggage checks and new aviation safety standards.

- Explainer

Can Democrats rewrite Trump’s war policies?

Can Democrats rewrite Trump’s war policies?

Could the US midterm elections force a shift in Donald Trump’s foreign policy? This explainer examines what Democratic gains could mean for the Iran conflict, Washington’s support for Israel, the crisis in Gaza, and military aid to Ukraine.

- Explainer

How do airports manage thousands of flights every day?

How do airports manage thousands of flights every day?

Airports manage thousands of flights in real time without creating a giant traffic jam. Air traffic controllers, airport systems, and operations teams coordinate runways, taxiways, and gates as a digital traffic management system.

- Explainer

More From This Author

- Headlines Today

Amir Khosru: Govt plans to turn Chittagong into economic, logistics hub

Amir Khosru: Govt plans to turn Chittagong into economic, logistics hub

- Headlines Today

Grand Theft Auto VI takes record $3.8 bn on first day

Grand Theft Auto VI takes record $3.8 bn on first day

- Headlines Today

Bangladesh now has 302 LEED-certified green factories, the most in the world

Bangladesh now has 302 LEED-certified green factories, the most in the world

- Headlines Today

Labour unrest: At least 50 factories remain closed amid work abstentions in Savar

Labour unrest: At least 50 factories remain closed amid work abstentions in Savar

- Headlines Today

BGMEA questions CPD's inflation calculations in garment wage proposal

BGMEA questions CPD's inflation calculations in garment wage proposal